Reviews provided by Syndetics
Library Journal Review
Every great artist deserves a great biography, and Swing Era bandleader and clarinetist Artie Shaw finally has one. Previous books focused mainly on his music, but that represents only his public identity. One of the most interesting aspects of Shaw's life was that while his fame came from the music he made, his personal happiness did not. Most musicians play until the gigs dry up or their life ends, but Shaw stepped away at the height of his powers, and Nolan (Ross MacDonald: A Biography) reveals many of the reasons for this. Conducting interviews with friends, colleagues, and the man himself, Nolan examines the full breadth of Shaw's life. Verdict Considering Shaw's early literary desires, his many marriages, and the intellectual intensity that led him to become one of the most famous or infamous figures in jazz, Nolan has crafted a well-written, highly entertaining, and informative biography. [A "Book Cheer" pick; see the 2/4/10 edition of our enewsletter BookSmack!-Ed.]-Peter Thornell, Hingham P.L., MA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
CHOICE Review
Nolan (journalist; author of Ross Macdonald: A Biography, CH, Sep'99, 37-0168) presents an intimate biography of Shaw (1910-2004), one of the most controversial US music entrepreneurs of all time. Offering a chronological treatment that begins with Shaw's childhood, the author captures the trials and triumphs of his subject's career and personal life. The book is rich with quotes from industry legends (in music, film, and publishing) and from Shaw himself. Although these quotes are sometimes digressive, they add considerable depth to the biography and provide context for understanding the sometimes-abrasive artist. Nolan mentions other swing bandleaders, military musicians, and bebop artists, but only in connection to Shaw. In sum, this a pure biography: it provides an elaborate description of one person's lifelong challenges in the volatile entertainment business but does not build a foundational knowledge of swing, bebop, or other music. Summing Up: Recommended. Lower- and upper-division undergraduates, graduate students, general readers. C. Wadsworth Walker Kansas City Kansas Community College
Booklist Review
In the late-1930s-1940s heyday of swing, fans had to be for either Benny Goodman or Artie Shaw (1910-2004). For Nolan's host of informants, of whom Shaw himself is most voluble, it was no contest. A question that arises while reading this enthralling biography is who was the bigger pain in the ass. If Goodman was miserly, mean-spirited, and by Shaw's lights, more concerned with the clarinet than with music, Shaw was astonishingly cruel to parents, wives, sons, and personal assistants, dismissive of his audience, and so perfectionist that he drove himself out of music a half-century before he died. Nolan deploys his interviewees' testimony so extensively, adeptly, and intelligently that most as well as the best of the text seems to consist of it yet doesn't begin to offer an answer. Instead, he gives the satisfactions of a true rags-to-riches story, complete with the spice of glamorous marriages and flings (with Lee Wiley, Lana Turner, Ava Gardner, etc.), and plausibly accounts for Shaw's huge character faults without obscuring his charm and prodigious talent.--Olson, Ray Copyright 2010 Booklist
Kirkus Book Review
Nolan (Ross Macdonald: A Biography, 1999) reconsiders the swing clarinetist-bandleader in a beautifully measured, unforgiving account. Born Avraham Arshawsky to Jewish immigrant parents, Artie Shaw (19102004) taught himself saxophone and clarinet as a boy, dropping out of school at age 15 to pursue music professionally. After apprenticeship with pianist Willie "The Lion" Smith in Harlem's clubs, network radio work and leadership of a failed big band with strings, Shaw rocketed to the top in 1938 with his version of Cole Porter's "Begin the Beguine." That hit and others"Frenesi," "Star Dust"established him as chief rival to "King of Swing" Benny Goodman. Shaw also courageously broke the Swing Era's rigid race barriers by featuring vocalist Billie Holiday and trumpeter Roy Eldridge. However, the ambivalent bandleader almost immediately began to flee the limelight. He publicly condemned his fans as "morons" and broke up his band at the height of its wild popularity in the first of several professional withdrawals. His incident-rich life encompassed eight marriageshis wives included Hollywood goddesses Lana Turner and Ava Gardnerand many affairs, a wartime tour leading a Navy band in Pacific hot spots and an appearance before HUAC during the Red Scare. He abandoned playing for good in 1954, and lived another 50 years, concentrating mainly on writing. Nolan, who interviewed Shaw and many of his band mates and intimates, appraises his difficult subject with a cool eye. His briskly written work lauds the musician's instrumental virtuosity and ambitious conceptions, but the author cuts Shaw no slack about his many personal failingshis arrogance, anger, selfishness, egocentricity and his horrific relationships with parents, wives and children. It's a multidimensional portrait of a brilliant yet self-absorbed autodidact who could never find happiness or satisfaction, even when his greatest fantasies of fame and success were realized. An exemplary work of jazz biography. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.