Reviews provided by Syndetics
Library Journal Review
Film critic Thomson (Have You Seen...?) updates his latest edition with more than 100 new entries. Initially conceived as "a collection of short essays of filmmakers.composed in the spirit of my own movie education," the book doesn't have separate entries for the films themselves. Rather, actors (actress Hanna Schygulla is notably absent), directors, writers, costume and set designers, and others are featured. From the small screen, readers will find information about Ken Burns, Johnny Carson, Lena Dunham, and Tina Fey. Most entries are short profiles, but longer ones cover major figures such as directors Ingmar -Bergman and Luis -Bunuel. Each entry contains birthdate and birthplace, along with death date, when applicable. Directors have their filmographies at the header while others have their films discussed throughout the text instead of consolidated in a separate list. Film career information can be accessed at many other places now, so the value of this work is that it offers Thomson's perspective and commentary; on Kim Basinger, for example, he asks, "Why did she marry Alec Baldwin?" He sometimes writes off a performance or film with a single word (e.g, "befuddled" for Leonardo DiCaprio's role in The Great Gatsby; "disgrace" for Life Is Beautiful). Bear in mind that books by other critics such as Pauline Kael or Roger -Ebert also provide collections of critical essays. VERDICT This standard film reference can update your previous edition. Useful for a critic's opinion when offering DVD advisory (shelve it near your DVD collection), especially for a quick career overview.--Barbara Kundanis, Longmont P.L., CO (c) Copyright 2014. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Review
When this book was first published in 1975, it ignited arguments among many film buffs who disagreed with London-born critic Thomson's strongly opinionated summations. This latest upgrade which includes 300 new entries promises to do the same. Thomson retitled it, he says, "because so much is fresh and different." Now that the reference includes talents who've shot to fame during the past decade or so, including Renee Zellweger ("great range") and Ben Affleck ("boring, complacent and criminally lucky to have got away with everything so far"), it is truly massive, running the gamut from Abbott and Costello, who achieve the "lyrical, hysterical and mythic," to Ghost World's Terry Zwigoff, "a rare, individual voice". A critical minimalist, Thomson often nails the essence of a personality or career in less than a dozen words, such as Johnny Weissmuller: "No subsequent Tarzan ever matched him the loincloth was retired." He deftly distills entire movies down to single sentences, with Internet-like linkages. Since his Haley Joel Osment profile sneaks in a critique of Spielberg's A.I. ("Osment was uncannily good as the robot/puppet coming to life, but ultimately betrayed by the inability of his director to keep control of the very ambitious material"), the hypnotized reader feels compelled to seek his lengthier comments on Spielberg: "Schindler's List is the most moving film I have ever seen." After the publication of a 1994 edition, the Internet Movie Database became one of the book's major competitors, linking nearly a half million performers with over 260,000 titles, but one still turns to Thomson for witty writing and potent, razor-sharp insights. With an immense passion for pictures, he plunges past the IMDb into the very soul of film. Agent, Laura Morris. (Oct. 11) Forecast: Older readers will want to replace their earlier edition with this one, while an author tour, radio giveaways and advertising in the New York Times Book Review and Film Comment will attract a new generation. (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
CHOICE Review
The fourth edition of this work, now a standard title for biographical reference in film, has approximately 1,300 entries, of which 300 are new and many others revised. Its rivals include the similarly evaluative, but heavily illustrated, more scholarly, and more expensive, International Directory of Films and Filmmakers (4v., 2000); David Quinlan's illustrated, briefly evaluative Quinlan's Film Stars (5th ed., 2000), with over 2,400 entries focused on complete listings of the subject's film, television, and cameo appearances; Chambers Film and Television Handbook, ed. by Allan Hunter (1991), with brief, unsigned, descriptive entries; and such earlier titles as The Great Movie Stars: The Golden Years (1970) and The Great Movie Stars: The International Years (1972), both by David Shipman. Thomson's book differs from these in tone. The author has encyclopedic knowledge and is gloriously opinionated; his provocative, authoritative voice engages the reader in a way the other sources do not. Exceptionally enjoyable to read, his book should find its way into public and academic libraries alike. It lacks only illustrations. ^BSumming Up: Highly recommended. All collections. C. Hendershott New School University
Booklist Review
This revised and expanded edition of an opinionated guide adds 300 new entries for important figures in film history (Graham Greene, Pauline Kael) and rising stars (Jude Law, M. Night Shyamalan, Reese Witherspoon). Thomson's updated assessments of the careers of people like Tom Hanks and Julia Roberts make fascinating reading.