Enhanced descriptions from Syndetics:
There was a time, five hundred years ago, when science was regarded as an art, and art as a science. And in the contest between the senses, the ear, through which we had previously received all knowledge and the word of God, was conquered by the eye, which would henceforth be king. A new breed of painters aimed to reconcile the world of the senses with that of the mind, and their goal was to conceal themselves in the details and vanish away, like God. A new way of perceiving was born. Anita Albus describes the birth and evolution of trompe-l'oeil painting in oils in the fifteenth, sixteenth, and seventeenth centuries, focusing her attention on works by northern European artists--both major and minor. As a scholar, she stands in the tradition of Panofsky; as a painter, she is able to see things others have not yet perceived; as a storyteller, she skillfully describes abstract notions in a vivid and exciting way. Like the multilayered technique of the Old Masters, her method assumes an ability to distinguish between the different levels, as well as a talent for synthesizing them. The first part of the book is devoted to the visibility of the invisible in the art of Jan van Eyck--his visual effects, perspective, artistic technique, and philosophy. The second and third parts are taken up with descriptions of the genres of "forest landscape," "still life," and "forest floor." In the midst of butterflies, bumblebees, and dragonflies, Vladimir Nabokov emerges as final witness to the survival in literature of all that was condemned to vanish from the fine arts. After a glimpse into the continuing presence of the past and some conjectures as to the future, the book's final part throws fresh light on the colored grains of the hand-ground pigments that were lost when artists' materials began to be commercially manufactured in the nineteenth century. The Art of Arts is thus both a dazzling cultural history and the story of two explosive inventions: the so-called third dimension of space through perspective, and the shockingly vivid colors of revolutionary oil paints. Albus makes abundantly clear how, taken together, these breakthroughs not only created a new art, but altered forever our perception of the world.
Includes bibliographic references and index.
Reviews provided by Syndetics
Library Journal Review
Artist and writer Albus presents us with an interesting little enigma of a book. Ostensibly tracing the birth of oil painting, Albus cloaks this story in a complex and often opaque cultural history of the 15th and 16th centuries. Focusing on a few key painters Jan Van Eyck, Rogier van der Weyden, Gerard David, Hans Memlinc, and a few others Albus attempts to clarify how two features of modern painting three-dimensionality and the vivid colors of oil paints transformed the art form. Though the reader is occasionally caught up in her interesting stories (on the art of curing tobacco, for instance), they detract rather than add to the coherence of her thesis. The combination of a specialized focus and diffuse style result in an ultimately unsatisfying book. Recommended only for large collections of aesthetic history. Martin R. Kalfatovic, Smithsonian Inst. Libs., Washington, DC (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Review
Painter and writer Albus (The Botanical Drama) has translated writings by the Goncourt brothers into German, and has illustrated books, including one by Claude Lvi-Strauss. This seems to have been insufficient preparation for tackling the present project, an examination of how the invention of oil painting by Jan van Eyck and his followers changed human perception. Secondary sources, particularly the great Erwin Panofsky, are quoted so heavily as to almost overshadow the project, especially since Albus's own reflections are often banal. We are told, for example, that on seeing van Eyck's Madonna of Chancellor Rolin at the Louvre Museum, "you have to rub your eyes." The prose is often redundant. In one instance, a kind of paint is called "a senile dotard." Some of this may be clumsy translation, which also refers to a "thick-as-a-fist black eye," but observations such as "[j]ust as not all art is art, not all science is science" don't help. Discussions of some painters less well known than van Eyck, such as still-life masters Georg Flegel, Johannes Goedaeart and Otto van Schriek, are somewhat more engaging, and in the last 60 pages, painters' colors are described in some detail and to some point. These pages might have made an interesting short book or pamphlet, instead of a welcome respite from a tedious treatise. (Nov.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
CHOICE Review
This handsomely illustrated book explores the development of northern European oil painting from the 15th to the 17th century. The first part, "The Visibility of the Invisible," explores the art of Jan van Eyck and displays writer-artist Albus's first-rate scholarship and technical knowledge. Her views are informed by her experience as an artist, and her skills as a writer make this an excellent account of the period. Her analysis of van Eyck's The Madonna of Chancellor Rolin, for example, weaves together a compelling narrative of the politics of the court of Philip the Good, the philosophical influence of Nicholas of Cusa, and the complex tradition of metaphors and symbolism. The technical aspects of painting in van Eyck's time--perspective, pigments, glazes, color theory, optics, etc.--are thoroughly described, offering the reader both historical insight and a richer appreciation of the art. The second and third parts are accounts of the genres of "forest landscape," "still life," and "forest floor." The final part concerns ten pigments no longer used and provides the basis for an often-unfavorable comparison with today's materials. All in all, this splendid volume would be a welcome addition to any collection. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty. R. M. Davis Albion College
Kirkus Book Review
Not exactly art history, not exactly critical analysis, but a rambling meditation on the aesthetics, materials, and purposes of Northern Renaissance oil paintings. Artist and writer Albus veers between sparkling observations, curious historical detail, and vapid pontifications on artistic genius, art criticism, and life in general. When she stands before specific canvasses and points out their most striking features, her comments are unexpected and illuminating: a three-page summary of van Eycks Madonna of Chancellor Rolin, for example, revels in every detail of the paintings miniature world (cherishing the tiny people who stroll along the winding path between the vineyards up to the wood on the hill, or chat to a neighbor under the lime-tree in a suburban square). Art viewers in the late Middle Ages and early Renaissance were trained to find innumerable layers of symbolism in visual images, and Albus provides leisurely, medieval-style explications of allegorical elements (including an explanation of the mysterious magpies in the Madonna that manages to be both playful and scrupulously researched). A discussion of a still life by Georg Flegel, a later follower of the school of van Eyck, unpacks the meaning of the elements it combinesA glass of wine, a clay pipe, a roll of tobacco with a little pile alongside, a sheet of paper, a burning fuse, and two strawberrieswandering over the history of smoking, the botanical and mythological significance of strawberries, the theory of the four humors, and the development of glass-blowing. Unfortunately, however, the author feels compelled to interrupt herself with mechanical attacks on theory in art criticism, accompanying her rants with grand-sounding but meaningless abstractions like Nothing living can absolutize itself in the flowing stream of time without drowning in it as a corpse of illusion. Still, the final chapter, which catalogues the thrillingly exotic and expensive materials (malachite, azure) used as pigments during the Renaissance, offers some thrills to make up for the pronouncements that bog down the work. Genuine insights into Northern Renaissance painting, mixed with minutiae and impenetrable philosophizing. (b&w illustrations; 12 pp. color illustrations, 10 color gatefolds, not seen)